I find it interesting to see how many bands Amiensus is
compared to. I’ve seen them compared to Borknagar, Agalloch, Oak Pantheon, Woods
of Ypres, Abigail Williams, Opeth, Dimmu Borgir, and even (quite puzzlingly, I
might add) Blind Guardian. While I do understand where most of these
comparisons come from, Amiensus is definitely more than just a cut-and-paste of
a half dozen different bands. It’s certainly difficult to pin their sound down
with any degree of exactness due to the way Amiensus has combined so many
different musical stylings. If I were forced to give a succinct genre
description to Restoration I would probably say progressive/melodic black
metal, kind of like Borknagar meets Agalloch, with more of a thematic tendency
towards the latter. However, that’s a misleading description because it leaves
out the fair amount of post-metal styled riffing and even the bit of melodic
death metal that appears on “Become the Fear”. It’s an eclectic mix of genres,
that’s for sure, and it makes one wonder. Whenever a band uses so many
different styles, asking whether the band pulls it off is a valid question. Has
Amiensus succeeded in combining their various influences into one coherent
album? Well, for the most part I would say yes.
I first came across Amiensus while trawling Bandcamp. It’s
definitely not the best way to discover music, but sometimes you’ll stumble
upon some real gems. And that’s initially what I thought Restoration was; a
gem, a veritable diamond in the rough. But that’s not exactly what I think of
it now. No, though I wouldn’t quite consider it a gem, it’s not too far from it. What I mean by that is,
initially, everything comes across as brilliant and wonderful. The harsher yet-not-too-harsh
blackened sections contrast nicely with the softer, folky parts and this really
highlights the band’s ability to use two very different ideas without sounding
random and haphazard. And that, besides the vocals, is the band’s main
strength. For the most part, they do manage to make things work for them,
especially in the album’s first half. But upon later listens, small flaws and
imperfections become apparent like awkward transitions between the harsh,
metallic sections and the softer ones, or the tendency to stick to a formulaic
song structure.
Most of the song on Restoration follow the format of a soft,
finger picked guitar or acoustic intro, followed by alternating sections of
black metal parts and softer parts. These harsher sections are why Amiensus
gets categorized as a black metal band. They’re usually of the heavier, slower
variety than the typical, blazing tremolo streams black metal is often
associated with. The harsh black metal styled vocals definitely contribute to
the classification. The softer, folky sections are where the Agalloch
comparisons stem from, though they often have keyboard melodies accompanying
them. That’s not to say that this is the
outline for the songs on Restoration, but it is noticeable and I would have
enjoyed a couple more adventurous tracks. As mentioned previously, the
transitions between the harsh and soft sections are sometimes lacking. Nice,
calming sections of introspective acoustics and keys are occasionally brought
to an abrupt and disconcerting end by the metallic ones.
Both the harsher and calmer parts are quite good when taken
separately, but when Amiensus combines the two styles is where they truly stand
out. Many of the harsh sections also use clean vocals, acoustics, and keys as
well, and the combination of heaviness and lighter parts lends a keen sense of
melody to the entire album. These sections will utilize heavier rhythm guitar,
melodic guitar, acoustics, drums, harsh vocal, clean singing, bass, and keys,
sometimes all at the same time. This may sound like a recipe for disaster, but
Amiensus pulls it off unquestionably. Such a thing would be difficult for bands
with many years of experience, so Amiensus’s success is even more impressive
for that. Credit must be given to the post-production work this album received,
because the mixing allows every part of the combination of sounds to shine
through. Quality of recording is somewhat of a controversial topic for some
people. Some claim that rawer production adds atmosphere and authenticity to a
performance, while others claim that shitty recording is just shitty. In this
case, having such clear production further allows each instrument to be heard,
which can only be considered a plus.
Now, the album’s other main strength is certainly the
vocals. Interestingly enough, every member of the band is listed as having
performed vocal duties, if only for a little while. Amiensus often uses a
hoarse, blackened rasp along with the black metal styled sections, and switches
to multilayered cleans for choruses. As I mentioned previously, the sections
where they use cleans combined with the harsher vocals is where Amiensus shines
brightest. I do feel the need to mention that the weakest section vocally was
Ken Sorceron’s (of Abigail Williams) harsh vocals during his guest appearance
on “Millenium”. His cleans are pretty cool, but someone from Amiensus should have
taken over for him on the harsher sections of the song. He did do the fantastic
mixing and mastering for Restoration, so his less than stellar vocal
performance is forgivable here.
Though I do mention that Amiensus is most consistently at
their best when combining the harsh sections with their softer ones and
layering cleans over everything, the best song on the album is “I Am”, an
almost completely calmer song. From the cello intro to the constant guitar
melodies and synthy keys, from the soft, rumbling drumming to the introduction
of the harsh, post-metal riffing of the second chorus, the entire song is
utterly fantastic. It’s been far too long since a song gave me chills like this
one, but that’s another frustrating thing about this release; though “I Am”
demonstrates the amazing ability this band has, they never again come close to
reaching the heights “I Am” does. Even though the least metallic song on the album
is the best, their other song with the least black metal in it is the worst on the
album. “Healer” is only four and a half minutes long, but it drags on in that
unbelievably boring way that Opeth is so famous for. Even though “I Am” is the
best song on Restoration by far, “Healer” is not too dissimilar to it, which is
why I said that Amiensus is most consistently best when mixing the harsher
black metal styled with the folky sounds and clean singing. It’s kind of
strange that I liked Restoration best when it was at its least metal points,
but also disliked it most at some of these points too. They can obviously do
this extremely well as “I Am” demonstrates, but I’m afraid that if they abandon
more of their metal leanings they’ll end up more like “Healer”.
To continue with that gem analogy, Restoration isn’t a
perfectly cut gem by any means. It has its flaws and rough edges like many
albums, but the parts that do work, work so well that it’s impossible to deny
that the band has a great deal of talent and passion. Restoration is more like
a semiprecious stone; it is very cool and all, but it’s easy to overvalue it
and get swept away by its shininess. I certainly enjoyed the album and it will
be interesting to see how Amiensus develops over their next full lengths. This
was perhaps too ambitious for a debut full length, but their split with Oak
Pantheon was excellent and they ironed out many of the kinks that held this
release back, so I’m hopeful that they’ll only improve. In any case, this is certainly
something to check out for fans of the numerous bands mentioned and well worth
your time.
77%
